ANOTHER TOP TWENTY LIST:

By bdpoe. 

Ask 700 music experts to vote on the greatest Rock and Roll songs of all time and you get a hybrid opinion. Something everybody can argue with. Such is the nature of opinion.

That said, here's my choice for the top twenty rock songs: 

1. Johnny B Goode, Chuck Berry.

Ask Keith Richards what the greatest Rock song is and perhaps he'll name a Chuck Berry Song! Indeed Keith has made remarks in the past as to Berry's influence on his style. Being a big Stones fan, I was glad "Satisfaction" ranked number one in VH1's poll, yet could there be "Satisfaction" without first having Chuck Berry ? 

2. She Loves You, The Beatles.

VH1 picked "RESPECT" as number two but "She Loves You" with its "yeah, yeah, yeahs" characterized the band that would change the music industry and lead the British Invasion. 

3. Good Golly Miss Molly & Tuti Fruti, Little Richard.

Little Richard claims he invented rock and roll. Indeed his influence is undeniable so much so that two of his songs tied for the number three position as opposed to VH1's pick, "Stairway To Heaven." One must wonder if Robert Plant's wailing vocals owe a debt to Richard's screaming deliveries. Covered by so many bands including The Beatles, Elvis, Mitch Ryder and Bruce Springsteen, the stars themselves endorse Richard's contributions. 

4. Bo Diddley, Bo Diddley.

The beat and the guitar riffs were unmistakably ahead of their time. Covered, converted and even ripped off, Bo may have been the first "Hard" rocker.

The Stones credit him as an influence. Bob Seger, Bruce Springsteen, Eric Burden, The Doors, The Band (as The Hawks) and others give the musical nod to BO.

"If you don't know Bo - you don't know Diddley!"
VH1 chose Dylan's "Like A Rolling Stone" as number four.
 

5. Be My Baby, The Ronnettes.

Phil Spector's Wall of Sound made this girl group the archetype for the Supremes.

Later the folks at MOTOWN did their best to emulate the sound. Had Ronnie continued her career rather than marrying Phil and being locked away, she might have given Diana Ross a run for the money. The Supremes went on to become the most successful American vocal group often challenging The Beatles for the Number one slot on the charts.
VH1 picked Bruce Springsteen's "Born To Run" as #5.
 

6. Blowin' In The Wind & The Times They Are A Changin', Bob Dylan Two ties in the top ten ? These two "protest songs" seemed to inject seriousness into pop music.

Dylan proved to the folk world that success could be achieved in writing fresh new viable material.

He gave Rock and Roll a consciousness that inspired John Lennon and others to write socially relevant lyrics giving the genre artistic credibility. Dylan has been attributed with starting the counterculture. Either of these two songs were far more influential than VH1's pick "Hotel California" by the Eagles.  

7. Purple Haze, Jimi Hendrix

From his debut album, the guitar playing and suggestive lyrics turned the music world upside down.

So unique and masterful the entire album constitutes 90% of Jimi's greatest hits. A definitive high point in the psychedelic era which inspired every guitar player to follow.
VH1 chose "Light My Fire" by the Doors as number Seven.
 

8. Boogie Chillun, John Lee Hooker.

This song from 1948 qualifies as one of the earliest rock recordings even if the term hadn't been invented yet. Note the similarities between "Hipshake" off Exile On Main Street by the Stones, " La Grange " by ZZ TOP and Hooker's Boogie. VH1 has the Beach Boys' "Good Vibrations" at this position. 

9. Shake Rattle & Roll, Bill Haley & His Comets.

For years Bill Haley was attributed as the founder of Rock and Roll. While musicologists place Rock's origins a bit earlier, a case can be made that Bill Haley gave us rockabilly.

As far as Alan Freed was concerned, Bill was the boss. "I'm like a one eyed cat peeking in a seafood store.." The Beatles' "Hey Jude" was VH1's entry at #9. 

10. Satisfaction, The Rolling Stones.

The Stones have said Keith laid down the chops for Satisfaction in Tampa Fla which indeed is where the airport was but the motel they stayed in was actually in Clearwater. It was there that Richards came up with the opening chords. Early social commentary in the lyrics and a harder tone became this band's calling card. They opened with this song on their last tour.

VH1 placed this at number one. 

11. Stairway To Heaven, Led Zeppelin.

The most requested rock song in the 70's according to FM jocks. VH1 placed it at #3 while "Louie Louie" came in at #11. 

12. Louie Louie, The Kingsmen.

It was rumored for years that the inaudible lyrics were allegedly obscene. Still this song became a party classic. When the words were finally published in the mass media it's lyrics were revealed to be quite aboveboard. "Yesterday" by The Beatles took this spot in VH1's poll. 

13. Layla, Derek & The Dominos.

Recorded in Miami with Eric Clapton, Duane Allman and members of Bob Seger's band, the song stands as Claptons' "Stairway".
VH1 picked The Who's "My Generation" for this spot.
 

14. Tangled Up In Blue, Bob Dylan.

A triumphal epic for Dylan. Significant because of it's complex story line and brilliant verse.

From his best selling album "Blood On The Tracks' many consider it Dylan's greatest. In so many songs Bruce Springsteen has attempted to capture the movie-like feel of Bob's lyrics earning him the title "the new Bob Dylan."
VH1 place Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On" at #14.
   

15. Ohio, Crosby Stills Nash & Young.

Powerful protest at a time when it was needed. Anthemic in proportion.

VH1's pick - "Johnny B. Goode" by Chuck Berry. 

16. Gimme Shelter , The Rolling Stones.

The 60's ended with a bang at Altamonte. It was "Satisfaction" for a new violent time. The song VH 1 pick for this slot is my next pick. 

17. Won't Get Fooled Again & Baba O Reilley, The Who.

Another Tie. Both from Who's Next. DJ's got lots of calls requesting a song called " Teenage Wasteland" which was titled "Baba O' Reilly."

Elvis' "Jailhouse Rock" took this VH1 position. 

18. Walk Like A Man & Sherry, Franky Valli & The Four Seasons.

Talk About high notes. VH1 picked "American Pie" as 18. 

19. My Girl & Just My Imagination, The Temptations.

Both the Temptations and the Four Seasons had phenomenal success and influenced pop and rock to such an extent that their inclusion in the top twenty is a must. Groups like the Backstreet Boys, Boy's To Men and a handful of similar sounding vocalists owe their existence to these two originals.
VH1 listed "American Pie" at 19.
 

20. American Pie, Don McClean.

It would be sacrilegious not to include this brilliant musical history of rock in the top twenty. Like the VH1 list, which placed the Beatle's "A Day In The Life" at number 20, you probably can argue with my picks as well....

BDPoe@aol.com


Musics, Book Review

Boomers International Web Site

Boomers International Club For Cutting Edge Boomers

This page has been accessed times since July 6, 1999.